I recently posted that we’re in the experience business, not the technology business. Of course, I didn’t define who ‘we’ are, but let’s say I mean mobilists. Oh, bother, I don’t define that term either - but you know who you are, don’t you? I’ll come back to names, titles and categories in another post. Or…maybe I won’t. I think it’s relevant here too.
I remember a great lecture in University that changed my outlook on business. It was a story about Parker Pens. Those who know me personally, please forgive me, as you already know that I tell you this story every time we meet, as if I don’t remember telling you before, which I usually do. I just love it so much and most people are usually too polite to say that I’ve already told it to them (quite a few times).
Parker Pens supposedly hired a management consultant, I think back before such jobs existed, which is interesting itself. Anyhow, their business was flagging and they wanted a turnaround strategy. After a while, the consultant reported back to the board with his recommendation, which they eagerly wanted to hear.
He asked them to tell him what business they were in, which didn’t go down too well. It seemed a rather impudent question and they almost didn’t want to reply, but he convinced them to humour him. They gave various replies, like ‘we’re in the pen business,’ all of which he replied ny saying ‘no, you’re not.’
Apparently they got increasingly irritate with the fellow and probably thought that they’d wasted their money. Like a tricky game of ‘I Spy,’ they eventually caved and said ‘we give in.’
He then went on to tell them that they weren’t in any of those stationery-type businesses at all. They were in the gift business. Despite all their flare in inks, ballpoint systems and goodness know what else in stationery technology, what mattered was the experience of receiving a pen as a gift.
The story goes that they focussed on how to improve the packaging, designs and selling process to emphasise the gifting experience, not the writing experience, and that this turned their company around.
Bear in mind that this was back in the 80s before Seth Godin and his kind were telling us about Purple Cows and other meta-business ideas about essentialising the customer satisfaction experience.
I’m always wondering what business mobile operators are really in. What’s the experience?
Technorati Tags: mobilists
[This blog has moved to here]



5 responses so far ↓
1 vd // Mar 6, 2008 at 12:13 am
I’m always wondering what business mobile operators are really in. What’s the experience?
None. The operators are the new ISP’s, but they don’t know that yet…
2 Paul G // Mar 6, 2008 at 5:15 pm
Certainly their lack of attention to the nascent ‘mobile computing’ experience is fast sending them in the ISP direction of irrelevance.
3 vd // Mar 7, 2008 at 12:27 am
The mobile operators, since 2003 (when HSPA was deployed at europe), are just “milking” the same “cow”, over and over again. Fooling the users with SMS, MMS and Video pulling, giving then a lousy (for over almost one decade) experience. I do understand that some people just use their phones for talk, but looking at the boom that the new generations are giving to the same services that exist years ago, I can figure out that when a heck of new experience arrive, it will be too late for the operators and their “cow”. Should they pay more attention to the ‘nascent’ world ? Sure. Do they understand that they’re running late on this cow? Well, here in Portugal they don’t.
4 Paul G // Mar 7, 2008 at 10:59 pm
I think some of them are realising it, but probably too late. They’ve squandered huge amounts of profits and many years of opportunity with the false dawns of WAP and picture messaging.
5 vd // Mar 8, 2008 at 12:57 am
Let’s take the video experience. What do mobile operators offer ? Nothing, they just say; “take the browser (opera), access some TV url, and “stream” video. Ah! For that you can take a regular 100MB data plan.” What ? Say again? 100MB a day ? “No, a month”.
That’s the situation here in the west cost of Europe
Regrettably, from my point of view, the operators are selling more and more the “mobile broadband” dongles than the “mobile phone internet”. People (customers) are still in SMS and MMS. Think twitter, mig33 and all others mobile startups.
ps: you can delete the previous comment.
Leave a Comment